5 Reasons Why Your Car Insurance May Have Increased

Reading Time: 3 minutes

by Marcus Fernandez
Auto Accidents
car insurance

You’re a careful driver with no accidents or traffic infractions on your record, so why has the cost of your car insurance gone up? You’re not the only one trying to figure out why car insurance premiums get more expensive. 

This article from the Tampa personal injury lawyers at KFB Law removes some of the mystery that has drivers all over the country scratching their heads, wondering why they must pay so much to insure a car. It gives you a peek behind the curtain at the factors insurance companies use to set car insurance rates. Number 4 on the list is guaranteed to surprise you.

Reason 1: A driving record with moving violations or accidents

Driving while impaired, speeding, and other violations of state traffic laws cause your insurance rates to increase. Insurance companies use traffic violations to indicate the likelihood that you may cause an accident resulting in an insurance claim.

Accidents can increase your insurance premiums, but Florida law protects you unless the accident was substantially your fault. For example, if you are legally parked and another driver crashes into your car, the company insuring your car cannot increase the cost of your car insurance because you are not substantially at fault. 

However, if you parked with a section of your car extending into the traffic lane, your insurer may determine that the way you parked made you substantially at fault. This could cause your insurer to increase the cost of your car insurance when renewal time rolls around.

Reason 2: Young or inexperienced driver in the household

Teenage drivers in Florida between the ages of 18 and 19 have the highest crash rates of any other age group. The age is slightly lower nationally, where 16 and 17-year-old drivers exceed all other age groups in their crash rates. Car insurance companies charge more for automobile insurance when a young driver lives in the household.

Driver inexperience prevents young motorists from recognizing and reacting appropriately and safely to dangerous situations. Studies show that teenagers are more likely to engage in risky behaviors, such as speeding, tailgating, and driving while impaired than older motorists.

Reason 3: You moved or bought a new car

Where you reside can affect how much you spend on car insurance. Insurers routinely look at the following factors related to where you live when determining the cost of car insurance:

  • Crime rates where you moved.
  • Accidents in the community where you live.
  • Incidents of insurance fraud.
  • Hurricanes, tornados, or other natural disasters may cause car damage.
  • Number of uninsured and underinsured motorists.

Another factor that may affect how much you pay for car insurance is purchasing a new car. You see a bright, shiny vehicle equipped with every bell and whistle. Your insurance carrier sees an expensive claim to replace or repair it when it’s stolen or damaged in a crash.  

Reason 4: Low credit score

Auto insurance companies rely on research to guide decisions about insurance rates. Someone financially responsible and with a higher credit score is less likely, at least according to insurance companies, to file claims. 

Whether credit scores are an accurate indicator that a person is likely to file an insurance claim may not be based on science, but insurance companies continue to use it to set rates except in a few states that have laws prohibiting the practice. If you live in Florida, your car insurance company may use your credit history to determine how much to charge.

Florida law requires insurance companies to inform you when a credit score or credit report is requested in connection with an application or renewal of a car insurance policy. If an insurer decides to increase your rate, refuse to renew, or take other adverse action, it must notify you of the reasons and how the credit score or report affected the decision.

Reason 5: An increase in annual mileage driven

It’s hard to argue with the logic used by car insurance companies that says a car driven 30,000 miles a year is more likely to be in a crash than one driven only 2,500 miles. The good news is that you can make annual mileage work in your favor.

If your annual mileage driven goes down rather than up, let your insurance company know. You may see a decrease in how much the company charges.

Contact KFB Law Today

If you sustain injuries in a car accident, your first call should be to Kinney, Fernandez, & Boire. Contact us today for a free consultation to learn about your right to compensation and what a personal injury attorney can do for you.

Related Blog & News Posts

  • florida statute of limitations personal injury claims
    August 11, 2026

    Florida Statute of Limitations for Personal Injury Claims

    If you were injured in an accident in Florida, one of the first questions to ask is: how long do I have to file a lawsuit? In many negligence-based personal injury cases, the answer is generally 2 years from the date of the accident or injury. This deadline was updated in 2023 under Florida law,…

  • is brake checking illegal in florida driver brakes to avoid collision
    June 8, 2026

    Is Brake-Checking Illegal in Florida?

    Florida Brake-Checking Accidents: Who’s Liable? Brake-checking can be illegal in Florida when a driver intentionally slams on the brakes or stops suddenly to intimidate, punish, or provoke another driver. Even though Florida law does not use the exact phrase “brake-checking,” this behavior may fall under reckless driving, careless driving, aggressive careless driving, or another traffic…

  • do motorcycles need insurance in florida motorcycle rider lane splits through tampa streets
    April 1, 2026

    Is Motorcycle Insurance Required in Florida?

    Do Motorcycles Need Insurance in Florida? In many cases, Florida law does not require motorcycle riders to carry insurance to register or operate their bikes. However, riders must still be able to prove financial responsibility if they cause a motorcycle accident that results in injuries or property damage. This makes Florida’s motorcycle insurance laws different…

Real Client Stories

We believe in providing exceptional service. Read firsthand accounts from clients who have entrusted us with their cases and experienced our commitment to client care.
Posted on Google
Kenya Bowers profile picture
Kenya Bowers
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
The staff here handled my automobile accident with ease, professionalism and kindness. They made a tough situation much easier for me. The women in the office were extremely polite and helpful! Communication is key to me and they definitely showed that. I pray I’m not in this situation again but if I am I would seek their assistance without hesitation!
Posted on Google
Juliet Murdock profile picture
Juliet Murdock
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I had the pleasure of working with Marcus Fernandez and his incredible team, and I truly cannot thank them enough. From day one, they treated me with compassion, respect, and a genuine commitment to getting the best outcome for my injury case. What stood out most was how they listened to me, advocated for me, and never made me feel like just another client. Throughout the entire process from consultation to settlement I always felt informed and supported. Communication was clear, timely, and professional, and I could tell that they really cared about both my physical and financial well-being. Even though my injury will always be with me, Marcus and his team lifted a huge burden off my shoulders. I’m beyond grateful for their hard work and dedication. If you’re looking for a legal team that will fight for you and treat you with care and honesty, this is the one.
Posted on Google
Justin Smith profile picture
Justin Smith
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I had a great experience working with Marcus Fernandez regarding an automobile accident. Marcus was very easy to work with and helped navigate me through the entire process. He was very responsive to my questions and concerns and left me having no doubt that my claim would be handled to my satisfaction, which it was. I highly recommend this firm and would not hesitate to call them in the future.
Posted on Google
Charleen Nicole profile picture
Charleen Nicole
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I had the pleasure of working with Marcus Fernandez and Rob Roy from Kinney, Fernandez, & Boire, P.A., and I couldn't be more grateful for their assistance. After being involved in a hit-and-run accident, I was left in a challenging situation both physically and financially. From the very beginning, Mr. Fernandez and Mr. Roy was professional, compassionate, and incredibly reassuring during such a difficult time. His excellent communication skills stood out—he kept me informed every step of the way, explaining the process clearly and making sure I felt supported throughout. Thanks to his dedication and expertise, I not only overcame the hardships caused by the accident but found myself in a much better situation than before. If you're looking for a lawyer who truly cares about their clients and delivers exceptional results, I highly recommend Marcus Fernandez and the entire team at Kinney, Fernandez, & Boire, P.A. They are top-notch professionals who will fight for you and your future!
Posted on Google
Sasha Marinesko profile picture
Sasha Marinesko
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I had a pleasure of working with Rob Roy and Marcus Fernandez. Both attorneys were incredibly understanding, professional and informative. Mr. Roy did a fantastic job throughout my healing process, explaining everything he was doing as well as checking on my recovery. Mr. Fernandez did phenomenal throughout mediation and negotiation. He was very quick, efficient, well-informed. He settled my auto-accident case and went above and beyond, accomplishing more than expected. Both attorneys were beyond doubt very experienced in their field of work. They made this stressful process easier and took an incredible amount of stress off me. I would recommend Kinney, Fernandez & Boire to everyone going through legal issues. Great job and thank you so much!
Posted on Google
Neil Heaven (DLP Studios) profile picture
Neil Heaven (DLP Studios)
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I definitely recommend this law group they have always looked out for me.
Posted on Google
Gina Williams profile picture
Gina Williams
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I like how they keep you informed about everything that is happening… I have no complaints.
Posted on Google
boat moter profile picture
boat moter
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
great company hard workers and another job well done
Posted on Google
Kings Made profile picture
Kings Made
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I want to give a special shout out to KFB.LAW. Everyone that works there is real professional understanding and patient. They are the best!! I want to say Thank you Marcus Fernandez for helping and guiding me in a positive direction. Every since my car accident I lost everything. My house my car my job and was severely depressed and injured. Every lawyer I went too told me I didn’t have no case at all. It’s nothing that they can do. KFB LAW works miracles and will never disappoint their clients. KFB LAW. Is the best. Call! Don’t hesitate at all. They the best.
Posted on Google
Tashona Wilks profile picture
Tashona Wilks
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
The best in the business!! He kept me informed throughout the entire process and fought hard for me. With his persistence and expertise he was able to get me a great settlement!!!
Rating
This law office is undoubtedly my number 1 go to and recommendation for anyone. The team is caring and attentive to your individual needs and efficient in their work. Ive gone here fortunately but unfortunately one to many occasions but they’ve had me evey single time. I couldn’t ask for better service. Thank you.
T
Tracy grutman
Rating
This office assisted me in pursuing a case after a car accident and helped answer all of my questions. From start to end of the case (which was completed in 6 months!), I felt like Marcus had my back and truly was there to represent and advocate for me. 10/10 would recommend to anyone in need of legal support.
A
Addison Hobbs
Rating
Marcus Fernandez is the MAN with the plan…Kinney, Fernandez &Boire,P.A and the GANG Was A Miracle Blessings Too ME!!!!!I would recommend them to anyone…Special Thanks To Mrs.DEE She kept me Encouraged &Motivated the whole way through definitely GREAT PEOPLE TOO HANDLE BUSINESS WITH
O
O C
Florida Bar Certified

Need Immediate Help?

Questions can’t wait — and neither should you. Start a live chat or send us a text, and get answers fast from a real legal expert.
Free consultation — 24/7
Trusted by Leaders
Rating
Rated 4.9/5