Tampa, FL
Consultations available 24/7

Personal Injury: When is the right time to settle?

Reading Time: 2 minutes

by Marcus Fernandez
Auto Accidents, Motorcycle Accident, Personal Injury
sign agreement

Being in an accident can be overwhelming and it is understandable that you may want to settle your personal injury case quickly. Doctors visits balanced with home life, meetings with lawyers criss-crossed with soccer practice. When human emotion and injuries are mixed together, it can be difficult to assess when the settlement you’ve been offered is fair, and when is the right time to renegotiate.

Facts of Your Personal Injury Case

There are different factors that should be taken into account when determining when is the right time to settle. Most liability insurance carriers do not attempt to resolve personal injury cases without making a settlement contingent upon a full release of all claims. Therefore it’s important to reach a point of maximum medical improvement (MMI) before attempting a negotiated settlement. Having the basic answers to important questions before it’s time to attempt a settlement is key. Ask yourself:

  • What is the final diagnosis of my injury?
  • What has been the outcome of my medical care?
  • Have I suffered a permanent injury as a result of my accident?
  • Will I likely need future medical care or will I suffer ongoing lost wages?

The answers to these questions will directly affect how a case is evaluated in settlement negotiations. Settlement negotiations should not normally begin until the injured party can fully consider the long term effects of an injury.

[Tweet “Reach a point of maximum medical improvement before attempting a negotiated settlement.”]

The Rules of Settling Your Personal Injury Case

Once you begin to negotiate it is important to weigh all factors. Most initial demands and offers leave both sides room to continue negotiations. After a few conversations the position of the insurance company generally becomes clearer and the injured party, with advice of counsel, can begin to consider a settlement versus filing a lawsuit.

There are basic rules of negotiating that are followed that may seem familiar; negotiate with confidence on your side, argue the strong points of your case but be aware of weaknesses and remember to give yourself room to compromise. Even when your case is seeking a settlement from an insurance company, understand that you are still asking for another person’s money. In the majority of cases insurance companies aren’t eager to give money away unless the evidence is there to fully support a demand for settlement.

Emotional Decisions

Emotions are real and should be recognized, but understand those not injured will not have the same feelings. Your lawyer cannot heal your injury, but they can help with economic losses and compensation for pain and suffering. This naturally requires objective and financially smart decision making.
A personal injury case cannot turn back the clock. Ultimately, the successful prosecution of a personal injury case will only result in a financial settlement. It does become a financial decision in many ways, with the goal of paying expenses and providing as much of a financial recovery for the injured person as the case supports. It is important to be realistic with your goals while pursuing the best recovery.

 

Related Blog & News Posts

  • what to do immediately after dog bite florida law aggressive dog about to bite human
    January 6, 2026

    What to Do Immediately After a Dog Bite

    What to Do Immediately After a Dog Bite in Florida An animal bite happens fast, but the consequences can last. From pain and bleeding to serious infections and legal uncertainty, knowing what to do immediately after a dog bite can make a difference in how well you or a loved one recovers, both medically and…

  • what to do if car insurance doesn't pay enough florida personal injury lawsuit
    November 26, 2025

    How Insurance Companies Try to Undervalue Your Auto Accident Claim

    What To Do If Car Insurance Doesn’t Pay Enough How Insurance Companies Try to Undervalue Your Auto Accident Claim When you’ve been in a car accident, you naturally expect your insurance company to step in and cover your medical bills, repair costs, lost wages, and other damages. But all too often, policyholders find themselves facing…

  • time limit to file accident claim florida fender bender car accident
    November 26, 2025

    How Long Do You Have to File an Auto Accident Claim in Florida

    The Time Limit to File Accident Claims in Florida If you’ve been involved in a car accident in Florida, time is not on your side. While your physical recovery is critical, understanding your legal rights and deadlines with the help of a law firm is just as important. Waiting too long to file could mean…

Real Client Stories

We believe in providing exceptional service. Read firsthand accounts from clients who have entrusted us with their cases and experienced our commitment to client care.
Rating
This law office is undoubtedly my number 1 go to and recommendation for anyone. The team is caring and attentive to your individual needs and efficient in their work. Ive gone here fortunately but unfortunately one to many occasions but they’ve had me evey single time. I couldn’t ask for better service. Thank you.
T
Tracy grutman
Rating
This office assisted me in pursuing a case after a car accident and helped answer all of my questions. From start to end of the case (which was completed in 6 months!), I felt like Marcus had my back and truly was there to represent and advocate for me. 10/10 would recommend to anyone in need of legal support.
A
Addison Hobbs
Rating
Marcus Fernandez is the MAN with the plan…Kinney, Fernandez &Boire,P.A and the GANG Was A Miracle Blessings Too ME!!!!!I would recommend them to anyone…Special Thanks To Mrs.DEE She kept me Encouraged &Motivated the whole way through definitely GREAT PEOPLE TOO HANDLE BUSINESS WITH
O
O C
Florida Bar Certified

Need Immediate Help?

Questions can’t wait — and neither should you. Start a live chat or send us a text, and get answers fast from a real legal expert.
Free consultation — 24/7
Trusted by Leaders
Rating
Rated 4.9/5